Custom Gifting

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Bar (8oz.)
One 8-ounce bar of Sharp New York State Cheddar, aged at least 1 year.
Our Price: $6.40

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Original Herkimer's Cheddar Cheese Balls - Assorted Flavors (10oz.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Cheddar "Cold Pack" Cheese Balls, coated in slivered almonds. Available in Sharp Cheddar, Port Wine, Garlic & Herb. When ordering, please indicate desired flavor(s).
Our Price: $6.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Cheddar Cheese Logs - Assorted Flavors (10oz.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Cheddar "Cold Pack" Cheese Logs, coated in slivered almonds. Available in Sharp, Port Wine, Garlic & Herb. When ordering, please indicate desired flavor(s).
Our Price: $6.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

NY Cheddar Cheese Square - Assorted Flavors (8oz.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Cheddar "Cold Pack" Cheese Squares, available in Sharp, Port Wine, Garlic & Herb, and Horseradish.
Our Price: $4.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Herkimer Foods Pretzel Dip (8oz.)
One 8-ounce container of Original Herkimer's New York State Cheddar Mustard Dip‚ not only a great complement to pretzels, but excellent on hot dogs and burgers too! Dippable Spreadable Microwavable
Our Price: $4.60

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Herkimer Foods Dark Chocolate Fudge Dip (8oz.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Cheddar, together with sweet dark chocolate fudge, will be a treat that you can't resist.
Our Price: $4.60

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Herkimer Foods Feta Dip (8oz.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Feta Cheese Dip. Try it with flatbread!
Our Price: $4.60

View DetailsAdd to Cart