Cheddar Cheese

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Wheel (5lb.)
One 5-pound wheel of Original Herkimer's Sharp New York State Cheddar covered in black wax. Aged over 1 year.
Our Price: $65.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Block (2 1/2lb.)
Original Herkimer's New York State Sharp Cheddar covered in black wax, aged a minimum of 1 year.
Our Price: $32.50

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Split Wheel (6lb.)
One 6-pound split wheel of Original Herkimer's Sharp New York State Cheddar covered in black wax. Aged over 1 year. Available in white or yellow.
Our Price: $75.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

3-year Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Block (2 1/2lb.)
Original Herkimer's Sharp New York State Cheddar covered in black wax, aged a minimum of 3 years. Available in white or yellow.
Our Price: $50.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Four 3 lb Wheels
Four 3-pound wheels of Original Herkimer's Sharp New York State Cheddar, covered in black wax and aged a minimum of 1 year.
Our Price: $160.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Bars (box of 12)
Twelve 8-ounce bars of Sharp New York State Cheddar; aged a minimum of 12 months.
Our Price: $76.60

View DetailsAdd to Cart

Aged Sharp NY Cheddar Cheese Wheel (3 lb.)
One 3-pound wheel of Original Herkimer's Sharp New York State Cheddar, covered in black wax and aged a minimum of 1 year.
Our Price: $40.00

View DetailsAdd to Cart